Summary + Thesis + Supports #2
Designed to optimize performance while maintaining safety
standards during underground excavation, the Herrenknecht Tunnel Boring Machine
(TBM) is a state-of-the-art piece of engineering while the Earth Pressure
Balance (EPB) TBM is fundamentally useful for softer ground and elaborate
geological settings (Herrenknecht, n.d., Our Tunnelling Technology section).
Other key elements of the TBM are the cutting wheel and screw conveyor designed
for the effective transportation of the excavated material (Herrenknecht, n.d.,
EPB Shield, Functional Principle section). Additionally, these devices are
gaining more popularity in urban tunneling projects because of the high level
of accuracy they can achieve with minimum surface damage. For instance, in the
London Crossrail project, eight Herrenknecht TBMs were applied and over 42
kilometers of tunnels were bored without causing any environmental disruption
(Herrenknecht AG, n.d., Highspeed in London section, para 2). Furthermore,
Herrenknecht is known to put efforts towards reducing the carbon footprint of
their machines and the energy expenditure while in use (Herrenknecht AG, n.d.,
Environment and resources section, para 1).
Thesis Statement: Herrenknecht's EPB revolutionizes tunnel construction through enhanced safety, efficiency, and adaptability to diverse geological conditions. However, challenges such as high costs and operational complexities must be addressed to maximise its long-term accessibility and sustainability in global infrastructure projects.
Support #1: When it comes to safety features, Herrenknecht's machines is unmatched.
Support #2: Secondly, Herrenknecht's EPB TBM efficiencies is superior to other companies in the same industry.
Support #3: Lastly, Herrenknecht's EPB TBM is able to adapt to most if not all geological conditions compared to traditional TBMs
If these are the main controlling ideas -- enhanced safety, efficiency, and adaptability to diverse geological conditions -- each one should appear as a primary support.
ReplyDeleteCurrently your alignment between the controlling ideas and the primary supports is not clear.
Dear Professor Blackstone, thank you for the feedback, will take note on it.
ReplyDelete